Even more weird twins

Man, twins are weird! Separated at birth, a set of twins from Ohio each grew up knowing nothing of the other’s existence. They were both named James on their adoptions (which might be a weirder coincidence of their respective families), both grew up to be police officers and marry women named Linda. They each had a son, one named James Alan and one named James Allan. They also each had a dog named Toy. They both got divorced, but later each remarried women named Betty.