Goat Cay looks nothing like a goat, and as far as I can tell has nothing to do with goats (though it is geographically close to those viral island swimming pigs). Tim Mcgraw and Faith Hill joined the island-owner party in 2008, and are currently in the process of finishing their private getaway estate on the 17 acre property. To get an invite, you probably need to be BFF’s with the country singers, like Gweneth Paltrow and Chris Martin, who recently visited the island.