The jokes first started coming hard and fast, one after another, after the Christian Nightmares Twitter account posted the picture of the T-shirt being worn. Internet users were quick to point out that the T-shirt’s slogan made absolutely no sense at all, and came up with lots of witty and quirky comebacks.

One Twitter user by the name of Andy Richter replied to the “Jesus Wasn’t Vaccinated” T-shirt with: “Neither was Satan.” Another internet fan, using the handle Participation Trophy Wife, got personal by stating that “Jesus didn’t wear T-shirts or have poorly bleached hair.” (Ouch, that one had to sting). While a third tweeter, Privileged White Guy, conceded that the woman “isn’t wrong,” before adding that “when kids die from preventable diseases, they aren’t coming back on Easter.” Comedy gold.