The good, the good-on-second-glance and the I-won't-ever-think-they're-good-looking. On the other hand: every single one is interesting and unique.

#2 It's like a Modigliani painting got run over by farm equipment.

#3 No one can flash a cadaverous rictus smile better than Mr. Defoe.

..."Dafoe"

#9 When your brakes fail, and you use your face to stop.

#12 When you have 'impure' thoughts about your pet Pug.

#16 If David Bowie finally got that sex change.

#17 Definitely "the voice." But, definitely a lot of charisma.

Shelly Duvall + Javier Bardem = Michael Shannon

#1 Chelsea Peretti has beautiful blue eyes and a smoking body.

I'll always go for oddly attractive over Vogue Magazine attractive.

#10 I first saw her in Muriel's Wedding.
Did not find her attractive at all, which was the point of the movie.
But, she has aged well.

#14 She looked pretty young in Donnie Darko playing the sister to her real life brother.
But that was a while ago.

Nobody mentioned Kate Micucci, from Garfunkel and Oates, Big Bang, and lots of other quirky stuff.
Look for the video of Garfunkel and Oates and Weird Al.

An old comedian once said "she has off-beat good looks, not beat-off good looks"

Hilary (1 L) Swank is trailer trash, too.

I don’t know who on this list is British, but many of them become famous for their actual acting skills, not their movie star good looks.

hmmm ugly hot celebrity.... when you, normal person, are ugly, you are just ugly

ok, my pick: anna kendrick