Recently in 2017, a video hit the internet of a young man in a red hood trying to save a rabbit from the Southern California wild fires. He was the internet’s new hero, beloved by millions. But who was he? Oscar Gonzales of Pacoima, California, claimed it was he. He said he was driving a friend home when he saw the rabbits and decided to save them.

His heroism turned to controversy, however, when other people online widely criticized him for risking the life of himself and the rabbits by potentially scaring them back into the flames.

Then things got even worse when it was revealed Gonzales might not even be the hero. A second man named Caleb Wadman came forward, claiming to be the real hero. He even provided evidence of his red hoodie and the testimony of a local vet that treated the rabbit.