In a move that surprised no one in particular, bachelor Brad Womack picked Emily Maynard in the season finale over fan favorite Chantal O’Brien. Womack famously rejected finalists DeAnna Pappas and Jenni Croft on the finale of his first stint as the Bachelor in 2007. Claiming he had worked through his issues, he finally got down on bended knee to propose to the single mom who had won over his family a few days earlier.