In April 2005, the Pennsylvania District Attorney called his girlfriend to say he was out for a drive and that he’d return soon. He never did, nor did he ever reappear.

His car was found parked outside a nearby antiques store, while his laptop was discovered in a local river, but there was never any sign of him. Whether he was kidnapped and murdered due to his high profile legal career, or if he took is own life, no one is certain.