Amy was on the Royal Caribbean Rhapsody of the Seas with her family, when she disappeared without a trace in 1998. She was partying with the ship’s band the night previous, and was seen sleeping on her balcony at 5:15am by her dad. By 5:45, she was gone. As a trained lifeguard, the odds are slim that she fell overboard.

When the ship docked in Curacao, the ship was searched, but Amy was gone. But here’s where it gets twisted. There was a lot of controversy around the crew’s reaction (or lack of one) when she went missing, suggesting that there was a sexual slavery/human trafficking aspect to it. This is further reinforced by the fact that tourists in Curacao have claimed to have seen her over the years, and a navy man in a brothel claimed that a woman named Amy asked him for help, that she was a slave.

As recently as 2005, the family received an anonymous photo of a sex worker on a bed, that looked suspiciously like Amy, but no could could track down where it came from.