Maple syrup
$20,000,000
Similar to the cheese theft, I’ll give you one guess as to where in the world $20 million worth of maple syrup was stolen from.
Of course it’s Canada, and Quebec in 2012 to be more specific. 720,000 gallons was stolen and eventually recovered from another syrup facility (though, that facility claimed they’d bought the syrup “legally,” which seems… suspect to put it mildly).